Interview with Janet Stemwedel

News, Opinion 27 Comments
By Dave Munger

Last week’s column on Seed attracted a lot of attention — but for space reasons I had to leave a lot out. I conducted several extended interviews, so I thought I’d post their transcripts here.

Janet Stemwedel is Associate Professor of Philosophy at San Jose State University, who blogs about issues of ethics in science, science careers, and science education at Adventures in Ethics and Science.

Dave Munger: What are the implications of the apparent gender disparity in science blogging? If you see it as a problem, do you have any examples of the negative effects?

Janet Stemwedel: It strikes me that there are implications on the producer side (for the people blogging, whether in networks or as independent agents in the scientific quarter of blogtopia) and on the consumer side (for readers).

For the woman who’s blogging science, being so outnumbered by male bloggers can mean that you spend a lot more time considering whether you want to blog about a particular issue that your male brethren are likely to ignore (or plow into without necessarily thinking through the complexities that you’ve thought to death, because they’re part of your daily experience). Or whether you can *not* blog about those issues this time (even though you have other things you’d rather be blogging), because if a woman in the science blogosphere doesn’t blog them, they might not get blogged at all. I suspect that women also have to spend more time defending their experience of their own lives when they share it on-blog than men do — because this weird thing happens when male commenters and other bloggers who are male will respond to your posts with, “It couldn’t possibly have been that way!” or “Well, I’ve never noticed anything like that where I am, so it can’t have happened.”

For readers, one of the implications is simply that there aren’t as many voices and views represented in what there is to read as there might be. Given the size of the blogosphere as a whole, that might not seem like a serious problem, but for the woman toiling away in a male dominated scientific field without a female support network in her three-dimensional world, finding the blogs of women in her field (or a field that sounds a lot like hers), going through the same struggles — that makes a difference. For the mom looking for information about the health impact of vaccinations, who doesn’t want snake oil but doesn’t want to be made to feel like an idiot, finding the blogs of scientists and doctors and other rational folks who are also moms makes a difference. The flash of recognition, that the people blogging about stuff that may be beyond your area of expertise are still like you in ways that make you feel able to related and invited to read more — that matters.

Munger: Ideally, should women be represented by equal numbers of bloggers as men? Or should gender balance match the actual gender balance in the fields they cover? Or would it be adequate merely to have improved numbers?

Stemwedel: I think my vision of an ideal situation would be for everyone who has something to say on a blog to find a place in blogtopia — including finding his or her natural audience and bloggy peer group. Not everyone wants to blog, and I’d hate to have people feel like they have to, whether to improve gender balance, or coverage of a particular subject or discipline, or anything else.

Also, since most of us have a little something called a life offline, it’s not obvious that you could easily recruit the “missing” female blogging representatives even for a field with equal gender representation in the 3-dimensional world.

Still, I think it would be good for blogging networks especially to try harder and find more women who are blogging (because they are out there, and many of them are fabulous). Indeed, I suspect the women who are blogging in fields where women are extremely underrepresented may be writing some of the most interesting stuff — so being content with a bloggy representative of the majority practitioner of that field is opting out of lots of good stories that a blog network’s readers might want to read.

Munger: Do you think women face unique difficulties in science blogging? If so, what are they?

Stemwedel: We seem to have to spend a lot of time reminding our readers (including our lay readers) that we actually know what the heck we’re talking about — including when we’re blogging very basic knowledge from our field. I don’t know if this is a unique problem for women science bloggers, but the activation energy for readers (and other bloggers) to assume that we’re confused, mistaken, or just plain dumb is a lot lower.

Also, I reckon we get a lot more sexualized (and threatening) comments and private emails from blog readers.

Munger: Do women blog differently from men? Is this a feature or a bug?

Stemwedel: I don’t think they necessarily do, but rather are perceived as doing so.

For about a year I was blogging pseudonymously (as Dr. Free-Ride), and I was routinely gendered as male by my readers. I don’t think my blogging voice, or the subject matter I took on, was markedly different then, but people seemed to take me more seriously. But then, when I started blogging under my own name (with my academic rank and institutional affiliation in the open, available for anyone to verify), it seemed as if some readers were more comfortable dismissing my blog as not serious, not scientific enough (even though I was blogging more straight science than I had before). It’s funny how a feminine name and a profile picture can make that big of a difference.

So, it’s really not the blogging style that I think is at issue — it’s the range of experiences that are being represented by the women and men blogging in their multitude of styles.

Munger: My analysis of the ResearchBlogging database suggests that many fewer women than men sign up for our service. Do you think there are fewer female science bloggers than males? Any guesses as to why?

Stemwedel: I have no good census data from the blogosphere as a whole or the scientific sector of it, so your guess is as good as mine.

I do have some hunches about the representation skew at ResearchBlogging.

One is that a lot of women who blog science are specifically blogging about their daily experiences as a women in a field that isn’t necessarily brimming with women at every level of the power structure. In other words, their blogging focus is being a scientist rather than on cool scientific findings that have been announced in the literature.

For related reasons, lots of the women science bloggers use pseudonyms (the better to process their experience without having that processing come back to bite them at work). Blogging cool new papers in your field seems like it has the potential to blow one’s cover.

Munger: Do you think there is a difference in how men and women promote their blogs? If so, what’s the difference?

Stemwedel: Could be. Part of it may be that fewer women are blogging to seek attention than to seek community — either intellectual community, or people who will help them strategize the next career step, or what have you. Another part may be that they just have more stuff to do in their offline lives. (Goodness knows there are plenty of university and professional committees that seem always to want another woman on them.)

Note: Last week I posted interviews with Jennifer Rohn and Martin Robbins. I don’t have a complete transcript for my interview with Kathryn Clancy, conducted by telephone, but she has written a blog post here that covers most of the issues we discussed.

27 Responses to “Interview with Janet Stemwedel”

  1. Fanny Esoimeme Says:
    December 2nd, 2011 at 10:09 pm

    Please let me know if you’re looking for a article author for your blog. You have some really great articles and I believe I would be a good asset. If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d really like to write some articles for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine. Please shoot me an email if interested. Thanks!

  2. Oren Bernabe Says:
    January 29th, 2012 at 7:09 pm

    Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some ideas for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great site and I look forward to seeing it develop over time.

  3. vanuit een technisch perspectief. Verslag van dit Says:
    April 23rd, 2012 at 2:42 pm

    This is the right blog for any person who wants to discover more on this particular question. You know a great deal its almost really hard to argue with you (not that I really would likely want…HaHa). You certainly put a new spin for the topic that is already been written about for several years. Excellent stuff, simply just superb!

  4. discount tablet apps for android Says:
    June 18th, 2012 at 9:55 pm

    Cool post . Thanks for, posting on this blog page dude. Ill email you some time! I didnt realise that.

  5. Cameron Jaji Says:
    August 21st, 2012 at 8:33 pm

    teen nudism household links MODERN NUDIST VIDEO ARCHIVE his net web page contains

  6. Dominique Keeth Says:
    September 19th, 2012 at 12:35 am

    Man that car is usually a beast

  7. http://www.squidoo.com/mickey-mouse-showercurtain Says:
    September 20th, 2012 at 7:10 pm

    “Wow, great blog article. Much obliged.”

  8. Portable staging Says:
    April 30th, 2013 at 9:37 am

    I would like to express some appreciation to this writer just for rescuing me from such a challenge. As a result of searching out via the internet and acquiring techniques that were not beneficial, I was thinking my entire life was over. Being alive without the approaches towards the difficulties you’ve sorted out by way of this posting is a serious case, as properly as the kind that would have badly damaged my career if I had not encountered your site. Your know-how and kindness in taking care of lots of things was superb. I am not sure what I would’ve done if I hadn’t come upon such a step like this. I’m able to at this time appear ahead to my future. Thanks for your time so a lot for this skilled and effective assist. I will not hesitate to endorse your web sites to any individual who really should get care on this difficulty.

  9. test0r0r0 download Says:
    March 11th, 2014 at 4:25 am

    Very good article. I absolutely love this site. Stick with it!

  10. sdorttuiiplmnr Says:
    June 23rd, 2015 at 3:00 am

    Yeah bookmaking this wasn’t a bad conclusion great post! .

  11. dautramhue Says:
    July 3rd, 2015 at 10:51 am

    thank you!

  12. oz Says:
    September 8th, 2015 at 4:26 am

    Nơi đây không đơn thiết kế nội thất nhà ống thuần chỉ là nơi ở nghỉ ngôi mà dự án Happy Residence hội thiết kế nội thất phòng ngủ tụ đầy đủ những gì một người dân thành phố hằng mơ thiết kế nội thất phòng bếp ước như không gian xanh, khu vườn, công viên xanh thiết kế nội thất nhà hàng mát nhưng ở đó vẫn có tiện ích nha dep 2016 kinh tế, thương mại, giáo dục, y tế, trung tâm tương mại… Hãy để chính dự án chứng minh giá trị bền vững với người mua nhà bởi chúng tôi tự tin vào những thành nha dep công tiếp bước trên con đường tu van thiet ke noi that phát triển đất nước nói chung thiet ke noi that can ho chung cu và khu đô thị nói riêng. Ngôi trường đạt chuẩn quốc tế giáo dục từ mẫu giáo đến đại học cũng là điểm mạnh trong dự án Happy Residence. Từ việc xác định hướng đi tương lai thiết kế chung cư biến nơi đây trở thành một khu kinh tế riêng biệt cho một loại hình hình kinh tế đồng thời cam kết lượng người dân đến ăn cư. —————————————– Vì thế khi khởi công mọi hạ thiết kế nội thất chung cư tằng kỹ thuật, kiến trúc, nội thất, tiện ích thiết kế nội thất căn hộ đều được tính toán chi tiết, khắt khe trong từng bước thiết kế nội thất văn phòng . Đã có nhiều du khách hỏi rằng thiết kế nội thất phòng khách vì sao các dự án thuộc Phú Mỹ Hưng đều được giới truyền thông quan tâm đặc biệt. Đạt được điều này thiết kế nội thất shop là một quá trình xem xét, xác định mọi yếu tố điển hình như thiết kế nội thất showroom dự án Happy Residence những nhà thầu xây dựng đưa ra giá tốt, giao nhà đúng theo thời hạn thiết kế nội thất biệt thự hợp đồng và luôn làm theo mọi cam kết thiết kế nội thất nhà ống sau khi người dân, nhà kinh doanh, doanh nghiệp, công ty đến ở. Mỗi nhà phố ra đời đều có một nội thất khác nhau, muôn hình muôn vẻ nhà đã góp phần làm giàu thêm nội thất nhà thiết kế nội thất phòng ngủ phố Việt Nam. Nếu như bàn nhựa, bàn sắt cho ta thấy được sự tiện dụng thì bàn gỗ tự nhiên lại mang đến cảm giác gần gũi, ấm áp. —————————————— Cách đây 3 tuần, mình thực sự vẫn còn học nấu ăn ở đâu rất gà mờ và xa lạ về việc làm phô mai bún riêu cua que cho con ăn. Chẳng là trước đây, cứ mỗi cuối tuần rảnh cách làm bánh tráng trộn , ông xã rất hay chiều các con và cho vợ con đến ăn phô mai que ở Lotteria. Khỏi phải nói con gái nhỏ nhà mình bánh bao chiên thích ăn món này vịt nấu chao thế nào. Mỗi lần đến Lotteria, cả nhà ăn uống tính sơ sơ cũng hết hơn 300k ăn vặt. Là mẹ mình xót sườn xào chua ngọt ruột lắm. Nhiều lần vit om sau mình muốn học cách làm phô mai que như của Lotteria mà không được. Trong khi con thì cách làm pate gan càng ngày càng nghiện món này quá. Mỗi tội giá của chúng quá đắt đỏ. 25.000 đồng mà chỉ mua được 2 que phô mai bé tí. cách làm bánh bông lan ——————————————- Pano quảng cáo hay biển quảng cáo quảng cáo lê gia tấm lớn ngoài trời là loại hình quảng cáo có kích thước lớn và thường đặt ở những nơi có vị trí trọng điểm, nhiều người qua lại thi công quảng cáo nhằm thu hút người đi in ấn quảng cáo đường để ý. Vật liệu thường dùng là Hiflex in phun (còn gọi là chất liệu bạt) dùng phổ biến cho ban ngày. Đối với in kỹ thuật số khổ lớn những mẫu quảng cáo ban đêm thì lại sử dụng đèn led, đèn pha chiếu sáng …. Thi công một pano quảng cáo hoàn thiện in băng rôn giá rẻ là cả một quá trình dài không hề dễ dàng. Đối với những khu vực thi công phức tạp hay những yêu cầu khắt khe doanh nghiệp, NEO IDEA luôn cố gắng hoàn thành đúng thời giàn cũng như chất lượng sản phẩm: – Luôn tạo ra những bản vẽ hoàn chỉnh, ấn tượng và sâu sắc – Đảm bảo tính an toàn, tính thẩm mỹ. – Tốc độ thi công nhanh chóng, thuận tiện và luôn tính toán lựa chọn phương án tiết kiệm nhất. – Chế độ bảo hành tốt. Công Ty Dịch Vụ – Sản Xuất Quảng Cáo Lê Gia Gia 51 Đường Số 3, Khu Phố 3, Phường Cát Lái, Q.2, TP. HCM Hotline 0977 532 845 Email ketoan.anhsaoad@gmail.com

  13. clicking here Says:
    September 8th, 2015 at 4:38 am

    Fantastic web site. A lot of helpful information here. I am sending it to a few friends ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thanks on your effort!

  14. 銉兂銈儸銉笺儷 搴楄垪 銈偊銉堛儸銉冦儓 Says:
    October 11th, 2015 at 6:20 pm

    ナポリ代々のサルトリアで、伝説のカッターであった祖父の名を継いだヴィチェンツォ・アットリーニが2004年にスタートした、スティレ ラティーノ(STILE LATINO)。ネーミングからもうかがえるように、“ラテン的”なデザインはアットリーニ家の長男らしいクラシコスタイル。幅広のピークドラペルが印象的な3Pスーツ(33万円)は、ダブルのベストが形成するブレストラインが実に洒脱だ。
    銉兂銈儸銉笺儷 搴楄垪 銈偊銉堛儸銉冦儓 http://www.cacwhere.com/jke/198-moncler-sdctmdu-xhzj.html

  15. Margo Says:
    October 13th, 2015 at 7:35 pm

    2 of the most common SEO mistakes for small companies I
    see are META that is not enhanced and/or that is not distinct for
    each page.

    My blog – Local Search Engine Optimization for Accountants (Margo)

  16. tour cù lao chàm Says:
    March 14th, 2016 at 4:51 am

    thanks for sharing!

  17. cho thuê xe máy đà nẵng Says:
    March 14th, 2016 at 5:21 am

    thank you!

  18. nha hang hai san tai da nang Says:
    April 1st, 2016 at 2:02 am

    thanks your post!

  19. công ty thi công xây dựng Says:
    April 23rd, 2016 at 12:57 am

    bạn muốn tư vấn về xây phòng trọ Bạn đang
    muốn xây một ngôi nhà theo ý muốn? Bạn đang có nhu cầu tìm đến một dịch vụ xây nhà trọn gói uy tín và chất lượng
    hiệu quả nhất So sánh với nhu cầu sử dụng của gia đình để quyết
    định xây to, rộng bao nhiêu cho vừa túi tiền đang có.
    Nếu nhà có 4 người thì chỉ cần 2-3 phòng ngủ + 1 bếp + 1 khách.
    Thêm ông bà ở chung nữa thì cần thêm 1-2 phòng, hoặc ông bà có thể ở
    cùng với cháu nhỏ, khi cháu lớn thì đã có thêm tiền để xây buồng
    riêng. Bắt đầu thiết kế cụ thể.Muốn Thiết kế nhà đẹp thế nào

  20. nba 2k16 mt sell Says:
    May 9th, 2016 at 11:00 pm

    Superb page, Maintain the excellent work. Thanks a ton!.

  21. csgo skins arena Says:
    May 9th, 2016 at 11:00 pm

    Great looking web site. Assume you did a great deal of your ownyour very own coding

  22. suoi khoang nong than tai Says:
    May 22nd, 2016 at 10:52 pm

    Thanks for topic!

  23. xn--empeocoche-w9a.es Says:
    August 19th, 2016 at 5:47 am

    Its always de same

  24. babycook duo darty Says:
    December 2nd, 2016 at 7:34 am

    Le Babycook est tres complet puisqu’il permet a la fois
    la cuisson vapeur, le mixage, la decongelation ou le rechauffage d’aliments : 4 en 1 !

  25. bijoux hermes Says:
    May 2nd, 2017 at 2:47 am

    comme onesmells en blood.I avait peur de soulever mes paupières, mais regardaient et voyaient parfaitement un-der les cils. La jeune fille alla sur ses genoux, et se pencha sur moi, simplygloating. Il y avait une volupté délibérée qui était à la fois thrill-ing et repoussante, et comme elle haussa son cou, elle fait son léché lipslike un animal, jusqu’à ce que je pouvais voir au clair de lune l’humidité brillante onthe lèvres écarlates et sur la langue rouge comme il léchait la teeth.37Lower forte blanc et inférieure ont la tête que les lèvres se sont en dessous de la gamme de mymouth et le menton et semblaient fixer sur ma gorge. Puis elle fit une pause, et je pouvais entendre le son barattage de sa langue comme il lécha ses lèvres teethand, et je pouvais sentir le souffle chaud sur mon cou. Ensuite, la peau de mythroat a commencé à tinter comme ceux chair fait quand la main qui est de

  26. hermes lyon Says:
    May 7th, 2017 at 4:35 am

    trouver des solutions. premier La Communauté de Sant’Egidio est devenu impliqué dans Mozambiquein 1976 par son travail avec des communautés très pauvres. En 1984, theCatholic archevêque de Beira fait appel à la Communauté d’organe soit plus profondément engagé dans les efforts de secours à la sécheresse et les conséquences ofwar. Sant’Edigio envoyé et distribué de l’aide humanitaire d’urgence, coordinatedand surveillé par des bénévoles de la Communauté, ainsi withmissionaries et Caritas, le Mozambique catholique organization.As de secours, il est devenu de plus en plus évident que les problèmes de la pauvreté pourraient notbe séparée de la guerre civile brutale en cours qui a commencé avec indépen-rence, la Communauté a commencé à se concentrer sur le problème de la paix. Itembarked sur un effort persistant et créatif pour promouvoir le dialogue betweenthe gouvernement et différents

  27. Jack Says:
    May 28th, 2017 at 9:55 am

    Thank for sharing your tips, It’s a helpful for me

Leave a Reply

Icons by N.Design Studio. Based on a theme by Ben Swift.
Entries RSS Comments RSS Log in